Talent Agency Scams: How to Spot Them, Avoid Them, & Choose the Right Representation for You

As a content creator, working with a talent agency can be an exciting step in growing your brand and expanding your opportunities. A legitimate agency can help you secure brand deals, media coverage, and collaborations that elevate your career.

However, the rise of talent agency scams has made it more important than ever to be cautious. Some creators have reported being allegedly scammed out of thousands of dollars by the talent agency that managed their brand deals. Not every agency has your best interests in mind, and some may take advantage of inexperienced creators.

So that is why we wanted to share some key tips to help you spot talent agency scams and protect yourself as you navigate this important decision.

1. Ensure You’re CC’d on Every Email

One of the easiest ways to stay in control of your business dealings is to make sure you’re CC’d on every email between the agency and any potential brands, clients, or collaborators. And if not that — having the entire email thread forwarded over to you. A shady agency might try to negotiate behind your back or hide details, so insist on being looped into all communications. This also ensures transparency and prevents misunderstandings when it comes to the terms of any deal.

Additionally, ask the agency if it is possible for you to have log-in access to the email address associated with them representing you. See, typically agencies will set up a new email address for you and you will be asked to have that email in the bio section of your socials so that that can be the first point of contact when brands reach out to you. Not every agency will give log-in access to the email, but instead will ensure every message is sent to you — which is still good enough.

However, preferably, still inquire about log-in access — especially if you often get emails from other people (that don’t relate to brand partnerships) such as someone from your audience needing help with something and they end up emailing that address instead.

2. Record Conference Calls Where Rates Are Negotiated

Whenever possible, record your conference calls — especially when rates, contracts, and other important terms are being negotiated. Many online conferencing tools allow you to easily record video or audio. Make sure to let all parties know the call is being recorded for transparency. And preferably, have this call on-camera because audio can easily be manipulated, whereas if you see the faces of people talking — you will notice if there are any edit jump cuts taking place. Having this recording on file can protect you from any misrepresentations or dishonesty.

3. Research the Agency and Its Leaders

Before signing anything, research the background of the agency and the individuals running it. Look for reviews online, check LinkedIn profiles, and search for any red flags. A simple Google search can uncover a lot about an agency’s reputation. If the leaders of the agency have little to no public information or a sketchy past, this could be a sign that the agency is not legitimate.

4. Reach Out to Current or Former Clients

One of the best ways to gauge the credibility of an agency is to reach out to influencers currently on their roster — or those who were previously signed. Ask them about their experience:

• Did the agency help them secure good deals?

• Were they happy with the level of support and services provided?

• Would they recommend the agency to others?

You can find the roster of various agencies within our free resource seen here.

Hearing from those who have already worked with the agency can give you a clearer picture of what to expect.

5. Insist on a Face-to-Face Call Before Signing

A trustworthy talent agency should have no problem setting up a virtual or in-person face-to-face call before you sign any contracts. This allows you to ask questions, discuss terms, and gauge whether you’re comfortable working with them. If the agency refuses to have a face-to-face conversation or makes excuses, it’s a major red flag. Legitimate agencies will want to build trust and will be open to discussing how they can help you.

6. Start with a Trial Period

Before committing long-term, ask if you can sign up for a 3-month or 6-month trial period. This gives you a chance to see if the agency is a good fit for you without locking yourself into a long-term contract. If the agency is confident in the value they provide, they should be willing to work with you on a trial basis.

7. Understand Industry-Standard Commission Rates

Contracts for talent representation typically follow industry-standard percentage ratio like 10:90 or 20:80, where the larger percentage is paid to the creator. Anything higher than this may be questionable. For example, if an agency is taking 30% or more of your earnings, you should be wary. Additionally, if they’re taking 20%, make sure they’re offering a broader scope of services.

Agencies taking 20% or more should provide significant value beyond just securing brand deals. They could also assist with things like:

• Content creation support

• Scheduling your posts

• Getting you press and media coverage

• Helping with making new products

• Securing speaking engagements & event invites

So, if an agency is only securing brand deals but taking a large percentage of your earnings, then it might be time to reevaluate the relationship.

8. Question Any Upfront Fees

Legitimate talent agencies typically earn their money through commissions on deals they secure for you. If an agency asks for large upfront fees or a signing fee, this is a red flag. Always ask for a detailed, itemized breakdown of any charges and consider seeking legal advice before agreeing to pay anything upfront.

Conclusion + FREE Resources

Finding the right talent agency can be a game-changer for your career as a creator, but it’s essential to protect yourself from scams. And if you are interested in gaining access to a list of 50 talent agencies that top creators are represented by - then please download our free resource listing them. We also have a separate free resource for tracking brand deals + pitching to brands

BONUS:

Upon downloading either of those free resources - there will be an option at checkout to bundle in access to 50 Brand Deal / Creator Event Matching Platforms. These types of platforms are one of the BEST ways to get brand deals — rather than individually pitching to brands.

Think of such platforms as a job application platform or email newsletter that notifies you of new scholarship opportunities. By joining such networks, often you would be given priority consideration when you show interest in a new campaign. Which could mean more money for you in the long run!

Love this Blog Post?

If so, feel free to give the writer a tip on BuyMeACofee and check out the learning resources, courses, and services we offer here at Edfluential.